Bad Rules

We take free speech for granted in America, unlike elsewhere. The  furor over that anti-Muslim video is the latest reminder of that. But freedom of speech is never safe, even here. Many colleges now  impose „civility codes.” Civility is nice, but enforcing a „civility rule”  against offensive speech would put an end to lots of useful provocative  speech. As a University of North Carolina student put it, „A picture of  Mitt Romney would offend 70 percent of residence hall students.”

Taping my Fox Business Network show at UNC, I also learned that  the college, to „protect” women, had dropped the word „freshman.” The PC  term is now „first year.” UNC also decreed that no student may  „implicitly” or „explicitly” ask for sex. (Then how do students get it?) Since sexual activity on campus continues, it’s clear that such  rules are often ignored. But there is danger in selectively enforced  rules. They let authorities punish those with unpopular ideas.

While in North Carolina, we ran across other assaults on freedom  of speech. Steve Cooksey started a blog about low-carb nutrition, which  included „Dear Abby”-style advice. The state told him that giving such  advice without a license is illegal! Cooksey stopped, but enlisted help from the Institute for Justice, the libertarian public-interest law group.  Together they sued the state for the free-speech violation. Unfortunately, a federal court dismissed the suit, saying that since the state took no formal action, Cooksey was not harmed. IJ will appeal.

My staff ran his advice by a Harvard nutritionist, who said it was  reasonable. But even if it wasn’t – even if it was stupid – people know that there’s plenty of garbage on the Internet.

„Why is it against the law to tell people to avoid grains?” Cooksey asked. „To tell diabetics to reduce carbs to help them normalize  their blood sugar? Why is that wrong?” It’s „wrong” when politicians are  eager to control everything – even speech about food. IJ lawyer Paul Sherman said „it would cost Steve thousands of dollars, and take years of his life, to get the dietitian license.” Not only that, it would take 900 hours of apprenticeship even  after Cooksey got his degree.

„Anyone who wants to can write a book about nutrition. What the  state of North Carolina has said is that you can write a book about  nutrition, but if you want to give one-on-one advice to someone, that’s  categorically forbidden.”

Vezi sursa articolului aici.

Facebook Comments

Lasă un răspuns

Adresa ta de email nu va fi publicată. Câmpurile obligatorii sunt marcate cu *